@dorion, are you sure you didnt have the thick white plastic coverplate over the back of it ? Most laptop LCD screens come sealed with this on and it cannot be removed (easily). These screens are not designed to pass light through (as the normal backlight is internal so gets reflected/diffused by it, rather than passng through it).
Sure, it didn't have the antireflection screen.
You could even put one on an old fasioned OHP (like you used to get in schools) and as well as just lighting up the image, it would project it on the wall!
Of course, but the lamp of the OHP actually produces between 2000 and 4000 lumens depending on the model.
A LCD panel usually blocks about 90% of the light if not a bit more. I guess you would need at least 1000 lumens to see your fingers through it. The point is, if you want to replicate the microsoft surface using that technique you should use a poweful lamp, and the resulting surface could also be a bit too hot on touch. You should also put a protective UV screen between the lamp and the panel or the panel would discolorize during years.