GadgetX() and GadgetY() with CLIENTCOORDS

Let's say I have a window that I opened with WINDOW_CLIENTCOORDS. Then I added a canvas which covers the whole client area. Shouldn't calls to GadgetX(window) and GadgetY(window) return the topleft coordinates, relative to the screen edge, of the canvas, and not the window?

Otherwise, when you do this:

SetGadgetShape window,GadgetX(window),GadgetY(window),CanvasWidth(window),CanvasHeight(window)

the window jumps `up` by the height of the title bar. The above code should not move the window or change its size at all. But GadgetX() and GadgetY() are returning the top left corner of the window border itself, not the gadget, yet trying to set the window's shape with SetGadgetShape() is taking into account that you asked for CLIENTCOORDS and is thus pushing the titlebar outside of what it thinks is the client area.

??????

Or is there some other way that I can a) read the window position and b) use that position in SetGadgetShape so that the top left of the window doesn't actually move? Does it mean I have to take out WINDOW_CLIENTCOORDS and try working based on ClientWidth(window) and ClientHeight(window) to get the size of the canvas, rather than being able to specify the exact canvas size?

Here is the original program in question - the SetGadgetShape() in the MOUSEMOVE event is where the problem is.

'MOUSEMOVE event with SetGadgetShape() is making the window jump up by the height of the title bar or more, due to GadgetY() returning the topleft of the window title bar, and
'SetGadgetShape() using the CLIENTCOORDS topleft of the canvas instead.



Strict 

Global GAME_WIDTH=320'ClientWidth(Desktop())
Global GAME_HEIGHT=240'ClientHeight(Desktop())

Local wx=(GadgetWidth(Desktop())-GAME_WIDTH)/2
Local wy=(GadgetHeight(Desktop())-GAME_HEIGHT)/2
Global lastdw:Int=GadgetWidth(Desktop())
Global lastdh:Int=GadgetHeight(Desktop())

'make a window
Global window:TGadget=CreateWindow("My Canvas",wx,wy,GAME_WIDTH,GAME_HEIGHT,Null,WINDOW_TITLEBAR|WINDOW_CLIENTCOORDS)'|WINDOW_RESIZABLE)
'SetMinWindowSize window,150,100
Global MinX:Int=150 'Minimum canvas size
Global MinY:Int=100
Global MaxX:Int=640 'Maximum canvas size
Global MaxY:Int=480

' create a canvas for our game
Global canvas:TGadget=CreateCanvas(0,0,GAME_WIDTH,GAME_HEIGHT,window)
SetGraphics CanvasGraphics(canvas)
SetGadgetLayout canvas,EDGE_ALIGNED,EDGE_ALIGNED,EDGE_ALIGNED,EDGE_ALIGNED

CreateTimer 60
Global xm:Int,ym:Int
Global oldwidth:Int,oldheight:Int
Global Resizing:Int=False
Global Paused:Int=False

Function MyHook:Object(id:Int,tData:Object,tContext:Object)
	Local Event:TEvent=TEvent(tData)
	If Event=Null Then Return Null 'Dont interpret if null
	
	Select Event.ID
	'Misc events
	Case EVENT_WINDOWACTIVATE
		Print "Window activated hook!"
		Return Null
		
	Case EVENT_APPSUSPEND
		Print "App suspend hook! - clicked on another window/desktop"
		DrawText "Paused",Rand(0,GadgetWidth(canvas)),Rand(0,GadgetHeight(canvas))
		Flip 1
		RedrawGadget canvas
		ActivateGadget canvas
		Paused=True
		Return Null
			
	Case EVENT_APPRESUME
		Print "App resume hook! - clicked back in our window"
		Paused=False
		Return Null

	Case EVENT_WINDOWCLOSE
		FreeGadget canvas
		Print "Window Closed hook!"
		End
	
	Case EVENT_APPTERMINATE
		Print "App terminated hook! It's all over."
		End
	EndSelect
			
	Select Event.source
	'Events from the window
	Case window
		Select Event.ID
		Case EVENT_WINDOWSIZE
			'Minimized/maximized?
			If WindowMinimized(window)=True
				Print "Window minimized!"
				DrawText "Paused",Rand(0,GadgetWidth(canvas)),Rand(0,GadgetHeight(canvas))
				Flip 1
				RedrawGadget canvas
				Paused=True
			Else
				Paused=False
			EndIf
			Return Null
			
		Case EVENT_WINDOWMOVE
			'WHILE the user is still moving the window,
			'update the game (updates onle when the user stopped moving)
			Print "Window Move Hook! "+Event.ToString()
			Return Null
		End Select

	'Events from the canvas
	Case canvas
		Select Event.ID
		Case EVENT_MOUSEDOWN
			'Begin resizing the window, activated by clicking in the zone
			'Could be detected with a custom resize gadget sending an event
			xm=Event.x
			ym=Event.y
			If xm>GadgetWidth(canvas)-20 And xm<GadgetWidth(canvas)
				If ym>GadgetHeight(canvas)-20 And ym<GadgetHeight(canvas)
					Print "Custom ReSize Hook begins! "+Event.ToString()
					Print "Mouse: "+xm+","+ym
					Print "Canvas: "+GadgetWidth(canvas)+","+GadgetHeight(canvas)
					Resizing=True
					oldwidth=ClientWidth(canvas)
					oldheight=ClientHeight(canvas)
				EndIf
			EndIf
			Return Null
			
		Case EVENT_MOUSEUP
			If Resizing=True
				Resizing=False 'Resizing ended
				Print "Window resizing complete"
			EndIf
			Return Null
		
		Case EVENT_MOUSEMOVE
			'Custom window resize gadget
			Print "Move Hook! Moved! "+Event.ToString()
			If Resizing=True
				'redraw game
				Print "Resized window - mouse moved to "+Event.x+","+Event.y
				SetGadgetShape window,GadgetX(window),GadgetY(window),Min(Max(oldwidth+(Event.x-xm),MinX),MaxX),Min(Max(oldheight+(Event.y-ym),MinY),MaxY)
			EndIf
			Return Null

		Case EVENT_GADGETPAINT
			'o/s requested refresh
			SetGraphics CanvasGraphics(canvas)
			SetViewport 0,0,GadgetWidth(canvas),GadgetHeight(canvas)
			SetOrigin GadgetWidth(canvas)/2,GadgetHeight(canvas)/2
			SetLineWidth 5*(GadgetWidth(canvas)/Float(GadgetWidth(Desktop())))
			Cls
			If Paused=True
				DrawText "Paused",Rand(0,GadgetWidth(canvas)),Rand(0,GadgetHeight(canvas))
				Flip 1
			Else
				Local t=MilliSecs()
				DrawLine 0,0,520*Cos(t),520*Sin(t)
				DrawLine 0,0,580*Cos(t/60),580*Sin(t/60)
				SetOrigin 0,0
				DrawLine 0,GadgetHeight(canvas)-50,GadgetWidth(canvas),GadgetHeight(canvas)-50
				DrawLine GadgetWidth(canvas)-20,GadgetHeight(canvas)-20,GadgetWidth(canvas),GadgetHeight(canvas)-20
				DrawLine GadgetWidth(canvas)-20,GadgetHeight(canvas)-20,GadgetWidth(canvas)-20,GadgetHeight(canvas)
				Flip 1
			EndIf
			Return Null
		EndSelect	
	EndSelect
	
	If Event.ID=EVENT_TIMERTICK
		'Timer says time to update
		If GadgetWidth(Desktop())<>lastdw Or GadgetHeight(Desktop())<>lastdh
			'Desktop resized by user using o/s?
			lastdw=ClientWidth(Desktop())
			lastdh=ClientHeight(Desktop())
			GAME_WIDTH=lastdw
			GAME_HEIGHT=lastdh
			SetGadgetShape(window,0,0,lastdw,lastdh) 'resize
		EndIf
		If Paused=True
			DrawText "Paused",Rand(0,GadgetWidth(canvas)),Rand(0,GadgetHeight(canvas))
			Flip
		EndIf
		RedrawGadget canvas 'Generate GADGETPAINT event
		Return Null
	EndIf

	Print "Unused Event - "+Event.ToString()
	Return tData 'Pass back unused events
End Function

'Add our hook to the system
AddHook EmitEventHook,MyHook

While True
	WaitEvent()
	'Handle unhooked or passed-through events
	Select EventID()
	End Select
Wend

Bump