I'm not sure GFK would react well to being told that his textures in his tennis game kind of suck
I wouldn't give a toss, to be honest. Because A) The comments various people made about the textures were acted upon, B) Only two people here have seen the game running and therefore they would be the only two people who's opinions I would value, and C) I didn't make the textures anyway - Psionic did. :)
Music, like all forms of art, is an "expression" and is something that should be shared, but not critiqued.
So you're saying we should not offer an opinion even when invited to do so by the composer?
I see...
If I'd said his tune was cool, would you still be telling me to shut the hell up? I doubt it. So don't give me any of that 'palm-of-hand-on-forehead' artiste bullcrap. He asked for an opinion, got one, and he didn't like it. That's the crux of the matter here.
Critiquing music is just as big of a waste of time as critiquing poety or classic literature. Trying to second guess what the artist "means" accomplishes nothing.
Eh? I don't care what he "means"! I just don't like the song. Why is this so difficult to understand?
If you only want to have a back-slap-a-thon with everybody else here, then please say so at the time of posting. I can slap you on the back and tell you your music is great if that's what you want, but what would be the point? It won't be true.
Yeah, I've got other stuff I'll just have to dig it up from my cd archive.
Fine - post away. Just because I don't like this song, doesn't mean I'll automatically write off everything else you ever do.